Tuesday, February 18, 2020

roux-ed awakening

actual image of yesterday's fare
for a while now, i've had this idea in my head that i should find (and try) a homemade-mac-and-cheese recipe.

up until about a year ago, i was a fan of the classic kraft boxed mac and cheese – you know, the neon orange, made-of-chemicals stovetop concoction that takes all of about eight minutes to make. i'd had it since i was a kid, when my grandmother would make it for my dad. the best boxed mac and cheese was, hands down, catelli... but they stopped making it a long, long time ago, so i had to settle for kraft – or, as it's been rebranded in canada, "KD." not nearly as good (it's all about the cheese sauce), but certainly better than all the other brands i tried once catelli's mac and cheese went to the great, and ever-expanding, "vickie's favourite products which have now been discontinued" graveyard in the sky.

one box of KD usually yielded two very generous servings, as well, so it was also a very very cheap option for a pair of very filling meals. but then they changed the cheese-sauce recipe. WTF? and the new-recipe sauce tasted terrible.

it wasn't just a rogue dud box – i tried a few boxes over the course of several months and all delivered the same bizarrely flavoured sauce. i won't even get into what they did to the macaroni noodles, which used to be nicely al dente after seven minutes in boiling water but which suddenly turned to mush after about four. i assume it was the company's attempt at making the prep even faster for those on-the-go types. but i am not on the go. and i do not like mushy noodles.

so...

after a mac-and-cheese-free year or so, i started to really get a hankering for it and reasoned that a homemade version – created from some fabulously reviewed online recipe and devoid of chemical additives – would surely be better than KD v.2.0. i asked mom if she'd be up for trying our hands at a from-scratch batch, and she said yes.

at this time i feel it important to make a confession: before yesterday, i'd never had homemade mac and cheese. in fact, i'd only ever had boxed varieties. (let me know if you need the smelling salts.) and i don't like cream sauces. full stop. these two facts should have informed me how this story would likely turn out, but they did not. live and learn.

anyway...

i scoured the internet and browsed dozens of recipes and read a seemingly endless stream of user ratings and reviews. i found a recipe that sounded good, seemed fairly straightforward and had a couple hundred positive comments from people who'd tried it out. "this could be it," i thought. "this could be AMAZING." it had a variety of cheeses, a crunchy topping and it sounded perfect for a february afternoon. my expectations immediately became unrealistically high.

mom and i gathered our ingredients and met at her place yesterday, "family day" in ontario, to create cheesy, noodle-y greatness.

only... it was not great.

wait.

correction: *i* did not think it was great. both my parents LOVED it. my father, who almost never compliments a meal, said it was the best macaroni and cheese he's ever had. he even had two helpings! and mom was over the moon with how it turned out. she is a mac-and-cheese connoisseur and has fairly high standards, so she knows of what she raves.

but i could barely finish the small serving i took.

i found it bland and pasty, even though it was very gooey and creamy. to me, it tasted like pasta in a milky roux sauce with a hint of cheese. i did like the crispy seasoned-panko-breadcrumb topping, which i applied quite liberally before the whole thing went into the oven, but that was about it. if i had to choose between a box of KD v.2.0 and the homemade mac and cheese, i'd actually take the box.

and that's when i discovered i am not a gastronome. i am a gastronot. though i fancy myself a decidedly discerning dessert fan, when it comes to certain foods, i go low(brow). i like lardy slab cakes and hostess sno-balls and, apparently, neon-orange macaroni and cheese that comes in a box.

and, as long as mom and dad are relishing the bounty of the leftovers, i'm okay with that.

4 comments:

Lou said...

Oh what a sad tale. What are you going to do? There must be other brands of mac and cheese out there that you can begin to try.

Vickie said...

i've run out of options to test drive here, so i may browse the mac-and-cheese section next time YB and i head to the states. are there any you recommend?

Lou said...

I don't eat M&C, but if I were looking, I'd go to some of the specialty markets--Gelson's, Trader Joe's, Mother's, Whole Foods.

Vickie said...

trader joe's: check. i'll have a look on our next jaunt to the U.S.